The Scottswoman, book review

Category: book Nook

Post 1 by TexasRed (I'll have the last word, thank you!) on Saturday, 19-Feb-2005 16:44:43

The Scots woman by Inglis Fletcher

Book Number:
RC 54013
Flora MacDonald, who saved the life of Prince Charles Edward Stuart (Bonnie
Prince Charlie) decades earlier, joins other Highlanders in the colony of
North
Carolina. Many Scots who side with the Loyalists are killed or captured at
the Battle of Moore's Creek Bridge in 1776.

This was a good book. I like the historical events and the way she
described them. This was the first of Inglis Fletcher's books that I have
read. I'd be interested to read some others.
Carla/TexasRed

Post 2 by Goblin (I have proven to myself and the world that I need mental help) on Monday, 21-Feb-2005 9:28:20

Sounds fascinating of course the story has been romanticised beyond belief by a succession of writers,who prefer to gloss over the carnage of those times, and dwell on the "romance" between charlie and flora which never really happened.

the truth is less attractive charlie died as a destitute and hopeless alcoholic, in Paris, not fighting heroically in the USA still that wouldn't make a good story..

Post 3 by TexasRed (I'll have the last word, thank you!) on Monday, 21-Feb-2005 12:38:14

This one tells it pretty much like it was, Fletcher didn't romantize the story. It was a brutal time and she told it that way. I know what you mean about other folks writings though.

Post 4 by Goblin (I have proven to myself and the world that I need mental help) on Monday, 21-Feb-2005 13:10:02

that's good it was a brutal time indeed the rebellion might have succeed if the clans had united behind charlie instead of fighting for position its the same old story in Scotland...Another good factual historical tale, concerns the MacDonald's massacre of the Campbells of Glencoe..stirring bloodythirsty stuff.

Post 5 by Goblin (I have proven to myself and the world that I need mental help) on Monday, 21-Feb-2005 13:10:30

that's good it was a brutal time indeed the rebellion might have succeed if the clans had united behind charlie instead of fighting for position its the same old story in Scotland...Another good factual historical tale, concerns the MacDonald's massacre of the Campbells of Glencoe..stirring bloodythirsty stuff.

Post 6 by Siriusly Severus (The ESTJ 1w9 3w4 6w7 The Taskmaste) on Sunday, 03-Feb-2008 23:02:28

It sounds good. Nice and historical.